Top 8 Dye Brands for Mahogany Hair Color

dark hair colors

People living in today’s world are very fortunate in that they can express themselves through a variety of hair colors. No longer are people stuck with the hair color with which they are born. Instead, they are free to experiment and to try out different options.

And, while wild colors have been popular for quite some time, mahogany hair color has really come into fashion lately. If you’re interested in trying this trend for yourself, you’ll be glad to know that there are many dyes that can allow you to achieve this luxurious color right in the comfort of your own home.

Be careful, though. Not every brand is as good as it claims to be. Luckily for you, we’ve got the inside scoop on the hottest mahogany hair dyes currently on the market.

Comparison Table




How We Chose Our Ratings



Before we dive in and share our picks for the best mahogany dyes, you may be wondering how,exactly, we chose our products and our ratings.

Don’t worry. Unlike some other sites, we did not come up with these ratings to try and sell you a product or even to make you think a certain way.

Instead, our only goal is to help you choose the very best dye for your hair and your needs. We want you to be able to make an informed decision about what you put on your hair.

In order to help you do that, we spent countless hours researching different products We looked at things like brand reputation, customer reviews, and so much more, all in an effort to help you make a smart hair dyeing choice.

Thus, you can feel confident in the fact that our picks truly represent the best of the bunch with no ulterior motives mixed in.


Buyer’s Guide



As you can see, there are a lot of things that you have to think about when choosing a mahogany hair color product. To further help you when it comes to choosing a dye, however, follow a few basic tips.


Do You Need Gray Coverage?



Gray coverage

Image via: Pixabay

First things first, decide if you need to cover gray hairs with your dye. Whether you do or not will have a big impact on which dye you should choose.

The reason for this is that gray hairs are a special breed. They are thick and wiry and are often very resistant to being covered by hair dye.

Thus, if you have gray hairs, especially if you have a lot of them, you are going to want to choose a dye that is specifically made to target gray hairs. Don’t take chances on basic dyes.


L'Oréal Paris Feria Multi-Faceted Shimmering Permanent Hair Color, 41...
  • FERIA IS MULTI-FACETED PERMANENT HAIR COLOR: Known for shimmering color & edgy colors, Feria permanent hair dye kits...
  • MULTI-TONAL, SHIMMERING FERIA HAIR COLOR: With 50+ bold shades ranging from deepest black hair dye to platinum blonde &...
  • L'OREAL PERMANENT HAIR COLOR: L'Oreal Paris Hair Color comes in multiple formulations and styles to deliver long-lasting...

A lot of people think that great hair color can only be achieved by going to a salon,or, at the very least, spending lots of money. However, this very affordable option  from L’Oreal proves otherwise.

Priced at around $10, though prices do vary depending on where you buy, this haircolor is remarkable for the shimmering highlights that it leaves behind when applied.

The color is also remarkable due to the fact that it does not drip, thereby reducing staining on the skin and clothing.

All in all, this is a basic dye, but it’s fairly easy to apply and leaves behind a shiny, shimmery color. We do think it could be more gentle on hair and more effective at covering dark hair. However, it’s still pretty great, which is why we give it a 2 out of 5 rating.

Garnier Herbashine Haircolor, 554 Medium Mahogany Brown
  • Exotic lus browns
  • Color creme with bamboo extract
  • Fortifies the hair cuticle for radiant, shiny color

This next option on our list is also a very affordable one. Plus, it’s super easy to find. You can pick this product up at your local grocery store, drug store, or department store.

We found that it was incredibly easy to apply. Plus, unlike many other cheaper brands, it isn’t tough on your hair. It effectively conditions and protects the hair when used correctly, ensuring that your dyeing experience does not cause damage.

This hair dye also includes UV protection, so your hair won’t fade even if you spend a lot of time in the sun. This can really come in handy if you are dyeing your hair in the summer months and/or plan to spend a lot of time outside.

The product is very resistant against fading in general and works well for gray hairs. Our only complaint is that it does tend to drip in the shower, even after a few days. Thus, you will have to deal with shower stains for the first few days. Aside from this issue, this product deserves its 2 out of 5 rating.

Logona Herbal Hair Color Mahogany, 100 Gram
  • Since we are not using artificial colorants, our hair colors are not meant to provide 100% coverage
  • Instead, our hair dyes mix with your natural hair color for a more natural look
  • Certified natural by BDIH and Nature

If you want serious coverage, then we recommend this dye from Logona. It is really one of the best we have found at ensuring that every single strand gets coated with rich, luscious mahogany color.

Plus, we found that its natural ingredients and the fact that it is ammonia free kept hair from feeling damaged after use, even if the hair was bleached before application.

What’s more is that the product contains UV protection, which keeps your color from fading, delivering very intense, long-lasting color.

The only downside was that the amount of dye you get per purchase isn’t great.Thus, if you have very thick or very long hair, you may want to opt for two boxes. Still, we give it a 2.5 out of 5.

L'Oreal Paris Superior Preference Hair Color, 5MM Medium Mahogany...
  • Our gold standard of beautiful, luminous, salon-quality permanent hair color
  • Formulated with Care Supreme Conditioner infused with Shine Serum, Vitamin E, and UV filter to lock in first day color...
  • Up to 8 weeks of fade-defying color

We know that we’ve already included a L’Oreal product on our list, but this brand has several great color lines.

One of the best is the Preference line, which includes a lush medium mahogany brown shade. It has soft red and purple tones that are very subtle. Thus, this is the dye you want if you’re hoping for mahogany that looks more natural than bright.

The color is very shiny and glossy for beautiful hair. Plus, it does not fade easily and, unlike so many dyes, we even found it effective at covering grays.

It has no ammonia and smells great. In fact, the only reason you might not like it is if you want a more “out there” version of mahogany. Those who like the toned down look, however, will love this product, which earns a 3 out of 5.

Revlon ColorSilk Hair Color, [32] Dark Mahogany Brown 1 ea
  • 100% gray coverage, ammonia-free
  • Revlon 3D Color Gel Technology for natural, rich, multi-tonal color
  • Long-lasting, natural looking, multi-dimensional color and shine that leaves hair in better condition

Fortruly glossy, shiny color, this product from Revlon is what you want.

Plus, not only does this product deliver intense shine, but it also allows you to customize the intensity of your color. Want a lighter, more subtle shade of mahogany? Leave it on for the lower amount of time specified in the directions.Want a more intense shade? Go for the full color time.

The instructions are easy to follow and make customizing your exact hair color a super simple process. This product also works great on grays and comes with a conditioner that will leave your hair post-dye feeling like silk.

Our only complaint with this product is that it fades a bit faster than we might like, but, luckily, it’s gentle enough to use for retouches soon after your initial color application. It’s cheap enough to buy regularly too, earning this product a fair 3 out of 5.

Schwarzkopf Color Ultime Permanent Hair Color Cream, 4.2 Mahogany Red
  • INTENSE COLOR: The breakthrough formula of Color Ultime hair colorations provide vivid color intensity and premium...
  • FADE RESISTANT: The advanced, premium formula of Color Ultime hair colorations defies fading for lasting vibrancy for up...
  • SHINE LIKE A DIAMOND: Color Ultime hair colorations provide lasting, incredible shine that is sure to stop the show!

While a lot of the mahogany hair color options that we have touched on so far have been pretty tame in their nature, this particular one  is anything but.Simply put, this is the hair color to go for if you want a truly intense mahogany, one that is more red than brown.

This color comes out very shiny and glossy like many of the other brands. Plus, it tends to maintain its luster for at least two months.

Unfortunately, while this hair color is pretty good at maintaining its glossiness, it does falter somewhat in maintaining the vibrancy of the color. This is to be expected with truly rich colors like this one, though, which is why we still think this product deserves a 3.5 out of 5.

Casting Creme is not a product line that a lot of people are familiar with. That’s a shame, however, because this mahogany dye is the absolute best that we have found for covering gray hairs.

Despite its potency, however, this dye is surprisingly gentle and even ammonia free. And, to further protect your hair, it comes with a great conditioner that will leave your tresses looking glossy and vibrant.

This is really a great dye, and we would have ranked it number one if it wasn’t for its short life span. On average, we found that the color only maintains its true intensity for about a month.

Still,it earns a 4 out of 5 for its brilliance and gentleness, as well as for its power over gray hairs.

Henna Maiden MAGNIFICENT MAHOGANY Hair Color: 100% Natural & Chemical...
  • Naturally adds color, shine, body and manageability, "Nature's Way to Cover Gray"
  • Safe, Natural, Cruelty Free and Made with Organic Ingredients.
  • Color lasts 4 - 8 weeks before beginning to fade naturally. You may re-apply as often as needed, when new root growth is...

Finally,it is time for the moment we have been building up to- time to announce our top color pick of all.

While it was no easy feat, we had to go with this henna-based offering

Like the last featured item on our list, this product also tends to be very good at covering grays. Setting it apart, however, is the fact that it does so with all natural ingredients, so you don’t have to worry about what you’re exposing yourself and your hair to as you dye it.

The product lasts for close to two months. Plus, best of all, as it fades, it does so gradually and naturally, so you won’t have to retouch nearly as often.

If you want hair color that will look great from the moment you apply it to the moment you re-dye it, this is the one for you. It’s the only product on our list that truly deserves a strong 5 out of 5 rating.


Choose the Right Applicator



blond color hair

Image via: Pixabay

Another thing to think about, aside from whether or not a product can cover grays is the type of applicator that it comes with. Some applicators are better than others. Also, different people have different preferences on applicators, and the type of applicator you’ll need will also vary depending on what you intend to do with your hair. Someone hoping to create mahogany highlights is probably going to need a different applicator than someone looking for all-over color, for example.

Fortunately, if do your research and look for detailed information on the type of applicator a product comes with, you can choose the best option for your needs. Also, you could go online and buy your own applicator that you could then use with any dye of your choosing. This can often be nice since it’s less limiting.

Whatever you do, the key is just to get the right applicator for your needs and purposes.


Be Aware of Allergies or Sensitivities



Finally, make sure you are clear on whether or not you have any allergies or sensitivities to products commonly found in hair dyes. Even if you don’t think you have allergies or have used a product before, remember to always try a“strand test” to ensure that the product can be used safely.


Start Shopping Today



If you can follow these helpful tips and the general advice presented here, there is no reason that you can’t end up with an amazing hair color and have an equally amazing dyeing experience. Shop carefully and do your research, and you should be more than satisfied with your new mahogany hair color, guaranteed!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Comment: